Court Upholds 5.5B Ruble Penalty on Rosnanо Ex-Managers
On May 26, the Ninth Arbitration Appeal Court rejected appeals against the ruling of the Arbitration Court of Moscow, which on April 3 granted
Consensus
- The Arbitration Court of the Moscow Circuit upheld the decision to recover over 5.5 billion rubles from former top managers of Rosnanо.
- The claim is related to the failed Plastic Logic project, which aimed to develop flexible tablets for Russian schools.
- The project was initiated in 2009 and ultimately did not achieve its intended goals.
- The court rejected appeals (including cassation and appellate) filed by the former managers.
- The case was heard in a closed session, with the court granting Rosnanо's request for closed proceedings.
- Rosnanо sought to recover damages from the former managers for their role in financing the project.
- Rosnanо also requested and obtained enforcement measures, including asset freezes on the defendants and their close relatives.
Points of divergence
- The amount claimed is 5.5 billion rubles, and the case involved a closed judicial session. — vm
- The amount claimed is 5.5 billion, and the court upheld the decision after a prior appellate ruling in May. — vesti
- The amount claimed is 5.6 billion rubles, and the court explicitly stated that the decision was upheld without change, with the cassation appeal denied. — interfax
- Marina Zakharova mocked reports about Chubais relocating to a beauty salon in Israel, which houses the Center for Russian Studies. — vm
- On January 30, 2025, several deputies of Chubais were detained in Moscow. — vm
- The court excluded Nikolai Tychinin from the list of defendants, as the claim was not satisfied against him. — interfax
- Rosnanо initially sought 3.89 billion rubles and $20.45 million, but the final amount was 5.6 billion rubles. — interfax
Coverage (3 sources)
- Court rejected Chubais's appeal against the decision to collect 5.5 billion rubles — Вечерняя Москва
- Court approved collection of 5.5 billion rubles from Chubais and former top managers of Rosnano — Вести
- Appeals to recover 5.6 billion rubles from former top managers of "Rosnano" rejected — Интерфакс