France's top court strikes down social media ban for under-15s
France's Constitutional Council blocked a law banning social networks for children under 15, reported France 24.
Consensus
- The French Constitutional Council declared the law banning children under 15 from social media unconstitutional.
- The law was passed by the French Parliament in July 2024.
- The Constitutional Council found the ban to be disproportionate and a violation of freedom of expression.
- The law required social media platforms to verify user age, but did not specify how.
- The Constitutional Council did not rule on the ban on mobile phone use in schools.
- President Emmanuel Macron has instructed the Prime Minister to draft a new version of the law.
- The decision was made in August 2024.
- The law was intended to take effect in September 2024, but was blocked before implementation.
Points of divergence
- The law was to be enforced starting in September 2024 for age verification and January 2025 for full implementation. — tg_bbcrussian
- The Constitutional Council did not object to the school phone ban, which could be implemented from September 2026. — interfax
- The law was intended to take effect on 1 September 2024. — kommerant
- The Constitutional Council stated that the lack of defined age verification methods could violate privacy. — interfax
- The Constitutional Council considered the exceptions for educational resources too limited. — kommerant
- The Constitutional Council did not object to the phone ban in schools, which could be implemented in September 2026. — interfax
- The law was intended to follow Australia’s example, which banned users under 16 from certain platforms. — tg_theinsider
- The law was passed with 279 votes in favor and 81 against in the National Assembly. — vedomosti
- France would become the first EU country to legally implement such a ban. — tg_radiosvoboda
- The law would have applied to platforms like TikTok, Snapchat, X, Instagram, YouTube, WhatsApp, and certain online games. — kommerant
Coverage (10 sources)
- The highest constitutional body of France recognized the law on banning social networks for children under 15 as not complying with the Constitution — BBC News Русская служба
- Constitutional Council in France blocked law banning children's access to social networks — Интерфакс
- Constitutional Council of France revoked ban on social networks for children under 15 — DW Главное
- French Parliament approved on July 21 a ban on social media use for persons under 15 years of age. France will become the first country... — Радио Свобода
- Constitutional Council of France revoked ban on social networks for children under 15 — Ведомости
- Constitutional Council of France blocked the law banning social media use by children under 15 years old, reports Fran… — Varlamov News
- Constitutional Council of France blocked law banning social networks for children under 15 — The Insider
- Constitutional Council of France revoked ban on social networks for children under 15 — Коммерсантъ
- Supreme Court of France blocked bill banning social networks for children. They deemed it unconstitutional — Фонтанка
- Constitutional Council of France blocked law banning social networks for children under 15 — Meduza
Key entities
- France
- Constitutional Council
- Emmanuel Macron
- France 24
- European Union
- Supreme Court
- AFP
- Moscow
- EU
- Reuters
- Council
- BFM-TV
- Higher Instance
- Supreme Constitutional Control Body